Previously, we discussed using morality, multiple intelligences, and scholarly habits to analyze characters. Not only does this add deep layers to questioning, but (more importantly) it provides opportunities to discuss gifted students’ unique emotional needs.
Personality types are another tool that serve these two needs.
Personalities Cause Conflict
Taking advantage of gifted students’ ability to abstract, begin with the big idea “Personalities Cause Conflict.”
Specifically mention forced group work in class, and students are sure to erupt with groans of agreement. Personalities do cause conflict.
Finding A Framework
The generalization is easy to understand, but a framework will be essential to discuss a topic as ambiguous as personalities.
The Myers-Briggs Type Indicators provide a simple but expressive way of analyzing personalities. They consist of four measurements, each separated into two opposite types. Pick one from each group and combine them to form a four-letter abbreviation such as INTJ or ESFP.
- Extravert: Action oriented. Gets energy from being with others
- Introvert: Thought oriented. Gets energy from being alone
- Sensing: Prefers step-by-step, detail-oriented tasks
- iNtuitive: Prefers to make leaps in thinking, avoiding details during tasks.
- Thinking: Motivated by logic
- Feeling: Motivated by feelings
- Judging: Likes to make plans and stick with them
- Perceiving: Avoids plans, wants to stay open
Note: I don’t like the labels. Judging and perceiving give no indication of their meaning. Judging even sounds inherently bad, so don’t spend too much time worrying about the names. Focus on meaning.
A Quick Quiz
Take a quick class-wide personality quiz (which you can download [here]) as a powerpoint). Emphasize that this is short and very informal.
Often, during this quiz kids might giggle or make comments as they note details that accurately describe themselves. You may even spot a couple causes for conflict in your own life.
Students might like to know how their classmates compare, so do a quick count of I vs E and so on.
Your gifted classes will probably have a similar spread to the general population, except your intuitive students may outnumber sensing students (which will explain why no one wants to show their work and also represents a way teachers battle gifted students’ needs.
Some students love reading more about their four-letter combination, so here are three resources:
- The official Myers-Briggs descriptions
- Wikipedia has an entry for each type
- MyPersonality.info groups information from several sources, although it tries to sell you more.
Discuss how each personality type is equally important.
We need intuitive people to develop creative ideas, yet those who prefer to hone skills through repetition are essential as well. Imagine if a surgeon liked to “try new things out” while operating on you! But think of the group conflicts that could occur if one member wants to stick to the known and one wants to venture to the unknown.
Discuss how judging and perceiving types might face conflict within a group. One wants to explore freely, while another wants to organize with a careful plan.
Perhaps have students invent situations where each personality type could shine. If kids can connect and respect each others’ personality differences, you’ve accomplished quite a bit!
Bring It To Characters
Once students understand these traits, move towards character analysis.
Ron and Hermione frequently fight. Could it be because one is detail oriented, likes to make plans, and enjoys time to think and read while the other is the complete opposite?
Cyclops and Wolverine show two different leadership types. Their opposite styles and constant conflict are a result of different personalities. Cyclops is detail oriented, social, and organized while Wolverine is an improvisor and prefers to be alone, keeping a few close friends.
Besides asking about character conflict, we can also analyze single characters.
- Does Katniss enjoy being in a group, or does she seek solace to recharge?
- Is she patient with details, or would she prefer to improvise?
- Are her decisions built mostly on facts, or mostly on feelings?
Finally, consider graphing characters in multiple dimensions using these traits.
Personality types give a wide range of interesting character questions, but also open up important doors to address students’ emotional needs.
Ever use personality-types in the classroom? Have other ideas on how to incorporate them? Let me know at email@example.com or @ByrdseedGifted on Twitter.
And, I’m a pretty strong INFP, in case you’re wondering.