The next Byrdseed.TV registration window opens in 9 days! Learn more.
Byrdseed Logo
  • About
  • Speaking
  • Puzzlements
  • ByrdseedTV
  • Big Ideas
  • Examples
  • Depth and Complexity
  • Archives

So… which is longer: a Ray, a Line, or a Line Segment?

This is a preview of a related Byrdseed.TV video.


How do we move the typical “ray, line, and line segment” lesson beyond merely memorizing definitions? How do we get students actually thinking about this topic?

As always, it helps me to ask myself, “What is interesting about this concept?” ([Not just “challenging”(https://www.byrdseed.com/challenging/)).

I realized that the concept of infinity was staring me right in the face. Infinity is a go-to interesting topic! I remember being a kid and struggling to imagine a line that truly went on forever. As I thought some more, I realized that both a ray and a line have infinite lengths. But a ray stretches into infinity in one direction while a line goes to infinity in two directions.

I knew I had my interesting idea! I had found some controversy!

As we learn about these three similar shapes, I want you to wonder with me: which of them is the longest?

Obviously, the line segment is out right away. It has a defined length.

So I want my students to go home pondering this baffling paradox: a line and a ray are both infinitely long, even though the ray has an end-point. Are they really the same length, even though one keeps going and one clearly stops? Are there different sizes of infinity!?!?!?!? 🤯

We’ve gone from “memorize-the-definitions” to “argue about infinity” by finding a bit of controversy.

Done For You!

There's actually a lesson at Byrdseed.TV that's specifically about this article. Check it out

This is an example of “Find The Controversy”

Every topic has some juicy controversy. Leverage it! Look for ambiguity, disagreements, dilemmas, and discrepancies in any topic.

See other examples of “Find The Controversy” ❯❯




📂 Also filed under Math.

Want to share something?

Everything written here is licensed as CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted. What does this mean?


Privacy Policy • Disclosure



Copyright © 2009 - 2023 Byrdseed, LLC